Black Friday discounts: how fashion brands can protect profit margins

By mid-November, Black Friday campaigns have already spent weeks dominating inboxes and retail calendars. What began as a single day of discounts first became Cyber Week and is increasingly turning into a promotional period that stretches across much of the month. For a fashion business, sitting it out does not always seem like an option. A look at the calendar and at competitors often makes taking part feel inevitable.

The campaign works. Sales soar, foot traffic and web traffic climb, and the team celebrates what looks like the best sales week of the year. But the picture changes at the end of the month: revenue has grown, yet margins have not kept pace. On some items, profit has shrunk to the point of disappearing altogether.

Taking part in Black Friday is not mandatory. Opting out can be a legitimate business decision, particularly when discounts eat into margins or undercut a brand's pricing strategy. For those who do join in, the key is not to confuse sales volume with profitability. Before launching promotions, businesses should know the true margin on each SKU, factor in shipping costs and fees, identify which products can withstand a markdown and review their pricing history. Anticipating the campaign's impact on cash flow is also essential, especially looking ahead to January.

That is one of the warnings raised by Talenom, a professional services firm operating in Spain, in an analysis of the mistakes that can lead small and midsize businesses to sell more on Black Friday while, paradoxically, earning less. Although the firm's advice is aimed at Spanish retailers, most of it applies to independent fashion businesses anywhere.

According to Talenom, many promotional decisions are made by looking at competitors' prices or revenue targets without calculating how much margin is lost on each sale. Ángela Cal Arca, business director for Talenom in the northern Spanish regions of Galicia and Asturias, sums it up in one question: "How much profit remains from each sale after the discount, shipping and commissions?" With that figure, she explains, businesses can work out how many orders they need and which products make sense to discount.

From there, the firm identifies five mistakes to avoid.

This article was originally published in Spanish with figures in euros. They are shown here in dollars for a US audience and are for illustration only.

1. Discounting without measuring the impact on margin

A 20 percent discount doesn't cut profit by 20 percent. The effect depends on the starting margin. Take a jacket that retails for 100 dollars and costs 60 dollars to source, leaving a gross margin of 40 dollars. Mark it down to 80 dollars and the margin drops to 20 dollars, so the retailer has to sell twice as many units to make the same profit. If it cuts the price by 30 percent instead, to match a competitor down the street, the margin falls to 10 dollars and it has to sell four times as many units.

2. Failing to calculate how many extra units are needed

Running the numbers before launching a promotion is essential. Talenom recommends estimating how many units would sell at full price and how many would need to sell at a discount to achieve the same result. For a realistic calculation, the cost of the garment alone is not enough. Variable costs on each order must be included too: packaging, payment processing fees, any shipping the retailer absorbs and the cost of handling returns, along with the marketing and advertising spend behind the campaign.

The firm points to another factor that can skew results. Some Black Friday purchases are not incremental sales but transactions that would have happened anyway at full price. Think of a customer who has had their eye on a coat for weeks and waits until Friday to buy it at a discount. The store makes the sale, but gives up part of its margin without generating any new demand.

So before applying a blanket markdown, it is worth analyzing which SKUs genuinely need an incentive to sell. Are they items from previous seasons, slow movers or overstock? Finding the break-even point for each promotion ultimately helps determine how deep to discount, which items to include and how much additional volume the campaign needs to be profitable.

* Before applying a blanket markdown, analyze which SKUs genuinely need an incentive to drive sales.

3. Overlooking the cost of higher volume

The cost of a promotional campaign goes well beyond the discount on each garment. On top of marketing and advertising spend come shipping, warehousing, order fulfillment, seasonal staff to handle extra foot traffic, and processing exchanges and returns. Extending store hours or bringing on extra staff during peak shopping days also hits the bottom line. If these costs are left out of forecasts, the campaign can look more profitable than it really is.

A jacket that sells for 80 dollars after a discount and starts with a 20 dollar margin may end up making only 15 dollars if the retailer has to absorb another 5 dollars in sales-related costs. The gap may look small, but it adds up. To get back to its pre-promotion profit, the business has to sell more units, and the thinner the margin on each garment, the harder it has to push to make up the difference. Talenom therefore advises calculating the full cost of the campaign instead of just subtracting the sourcing or manufacturing cost from the retail price.

4. Advertising a "was" price that breaks the rules

How discounts are communicated also requires care. In the European Union, where Talenom operates, any announced price reduction must show the previous price alongside the new one. As a general rule, that reference price must be the lowest price charged for the same product in the previous 30 days, and the discount percentage must be calculated from that figure.

This rule matters most during campaigns like Black Friday, when many retailers change their prices several times in a few weeks. Say a sweater sold for 80 dollars in a late-October promotion, went back to its regular price of 100 dollars, and is now marked down to 70 dollars for Black Friday. In that case the biggest discount the retailer can advertise is 12.5 percent, not the 30 percent it would get by comparing the sale price with 100 dollars.

The 30-day rule is EU law (the Omnibus Directive) and does not apply in the US, where former-price claims fall under the FTC's Guides Against Deceptive Pricing and state consumer protection laws. Consider adding a line on the US rules.

To avoid mistakes, Talenom recommends reviewing pricing history before launching any promotion and checking that prices are consistent across every point of sale. That includes ads, online product pages, in-store hang tags and signage, and the final amount charged at checkout.

"Keeping a pricing log by product and channel, along with a copy of the advertisements, makes verification easier if a complaint arises," notes Cal Arca. The firm also reminds retailers that failing to meet these obligations can lead to enforcement action and fines from consumer protection authorities. Businesses that sell across several channels, such as brick-and-mortar stores, their own e-commerce site or marketplaces, should keep a separate pricing record for each.

5. Thinking the campaign ends on Cyber Monday

Black Friday is only the start of one of the busiest stretches of the year for fashion retail. The holiday season and post-holiday sales follow right behind, creating three peaks that account for a large share of annual revenue while putting more operational and financial pressure on small businesses. Retailers have to secure more inventory, pay suppliers up front, add staff and absorb new expenses. On top of that comes the tax bill that higher sales bring, which also needs to be built into financial planning.

That is why Talenom stresses planning ahead. Forecasting staffing needs, keeping tax deadlines in mind and keeping a tight grip on cash flow are key to getting through these months without financial strain. A campaign can post strong sales while generating little margin and tying up a large share of available cash. The risk is reaching December without enough money to restock or cover expenses for the weeks ahead.


OR CONTINUE WITH
Black Friday
Sales